If you’re in Puyallup, Washington, and craving Italian food, Casa Mia Italian Restaurant is a must-visit. Located at 505 N Meridian, Puyallup, WA 98371, this restaurant has been serving delicious Italian dishes for decades. With its rich history, fresh ingredients, and warm atmosphere, Casa Mia is a favorite for locals and visitors alike.

 

A Legacy of Authentic Italian Cuisine

Casa Mia’s story began in 1952 when Phil Bellofatto, an Italian-American from New York, opened the first location in Hoquiam, Washington. At a time when pizza was virtually unknown in the Pacific Northwest, Phil introduced the region to authentic Italian flavors. Over the years, Casa Mia has expanded while staying true to its roots—handmade recipes and a dedication to quality.

The Puyallup location carries on this tradition with its menu of handcrafted pizzas, hearty pastas, and other classic Italian dishes. Every bite reflects the passion and care that has defined Casa Mia for over 70 years.

 

What Makes Casa Mia Special?

Casa Mia stands out for its commitment to freshness and authenticity. The pizza dough is made fresh daily, hand-tossed by skilled chefs, and baked on a stone hearth for the perfect texture. Their tomato sauce is simmered for six hours to create a deep, flavorful base for their pasta dishes. Toppings are sourced locally whenever possible, ensuring every dish bursts with flavor.

The restaurant also caters to modern dietary preferences with options like gluten-free pizza crusts and lighter dishes such as salads or risottos. Whether you’re dining in or ordering takeout, you can always count on fresh ingredients and bold flavors.

 

Menu Highlights

Casa Mia’s menu offers something for everyone. Here are some standout dishes:

  • Hand-Tossed Pizzas: Try their award-winning Pizza Sole with creamy Gorgonzola sauce or customize your own with a variety of toppings.

  • Pasta Dishes: Favorites include Spinach Cheese Ravioli ($19) and Chicken Carbonara. The Terra Mare Penne is another hit, combining seafood and chicken in a rich sauce.

  • Calzones: These stuffed delights are generously filled with cheese and your choice of toppings ($14.79).

  • Salads: The house salad with mozzarella cheese and black olives is simple yet satisfying.

  • Desserts: Don’t miss their homemade tiramisu—a sweet ending to your meal.

For those looking to try something new, keep an eye out for seasonal specials or unique creations like the Italian BLT or mushroom risotto.

 

Hours of Operation

Casa Mia in Puyallup is open throughout the week with convenient hours:

  • Monday–Thursday: 10:30 AM – 8:30 PM

  • Friday: 10:30 AM – 9:00 PM

  • Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

  • Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM

Whether you’re stopping by for lunch or dinner, you’ll find the doors open to welcome you.

 

A Cozy Atmosphere

The moment you step inside Casa Mia, you’re greeted by a warm and inviting ambiance. The décor combines traditional Italian touches with a casual vibe that makes it perfect for family dinners or date nights. The friendly staff go above and beyond to make sure every guest feels at home.

Even when the restaurant gets busy (which it often does), service remains prompt and attentive. Many customers rave about how quickly food arrives at their table without sacrificing quality.

 

Catering and Community Involvement

Casa Mia isn’t just a great place to dine—it’s also a fantastic option for catering events. Whether you’re hosting a wedding, corporate meeting, or birthday party, they offer customizable catering packages featuring their signature dishes.

The restaurant also takes pride in being part of the local community. From supporting local suppliers to participating in community events, Casa Mia has become more than just a place to eat; it’s part of Puyallup’s fabric.

 

Customer Reviews

Casa Mia has earned glowing reviews from diners who praise both the food and service. One reviewer described it as “by far the best” restaurant they’ve visited in Puyallup. Another highlighted the generous portions and flavorful dishes like blackened chicken pasta. Whether it’s your first visit or your tenth, Casa Mia consistently delivers an excellent dining experience.

 

Why Visit Casa Mia?

Casa Mia offers more than just food—it provides an experience rooted in tradition and quality. Here’s why you should give it a try:

  • Authentic recipes passed down through generations

  • Freshly prepared ingredients for every dish

  • A welcoming atmosphere suitable for all occasions

  • Convenient location in downtown Puyallup

  • Options for dine-in, takeout, or catering

If you’re looking for Italian food that hits all the right notes—flavorful, hearty, and satisfying—Casa Mia is the place to go.

 

Plan Your Visit Today

Next time you’re craving pizza or pasta in Puyallup, head over to Casa Mia at 505 N Meridian. Whether you’re dining solo or bringing the whole family along, you’ll leave happy and full. With its rich history, delicious menu options, and friendly service, Casa Mia continues to be one of Puyallup’s favorite dining spots!

 

 

Sources: casamiapuyallup.toast.site, yelp.com
Header Image Source: casamiapuyallup.toast.site