EVERYTHING PUYALLUP

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Pizza Pie Lovers Rejoice: Discovering Puyallup’s Top Pizza Spots

by | Jul 10, 2024

Pizza, universally recognized as a symbol of gathering, represents more than just a meal—it embodies warmth, community, and an unparalleled capacity to bring us together. Puyallup, a charming city with a rich palette of local eats, boasts an array of pizza spots that locals swear by. From the thin crust lovers to those who indulge in the deep-dish delight, there’s a slice for every preference. Let’s embark on a culinary journey through Puyallup’s pizza landscape, uncovering the crusts and toppings that set each establishment apart and the communal joy they bring to every table.

In Puyallup, pizza isn’t just food; it’s a celebration of local flavor, craftsmanship, and the joy of sharing. Each pizza spot, with its unique approach to this beloved dish, contributes to the tapestry of the town’s dining scene. Whether it’s a family dinner, a gathering of friends, or a casual night out, a pizza meal in Puyallup promises more than just satisfaction; it delivers an experience that binds the community, one slice at a time. So, let’s raise a slice to the pizza joints that make Puyallup a slice above the rest.

Fat Zachs Pizza FAMOUS No Big Dill

Fat Zachs Pizza FAMOUS No Big Dill Pie – Source: Fat Zach’s Pizza Facebook Page @FatZachsPizza

Fat Zach’s Pizza, nestled in the vibrant communities of Downtown Puyallup and South Hill Puyallup, has fast become a local favorite for pizza enthusiasts. Known for their handcrafted, wood-fired pizzas, this beloved pizzeria boasts a cozy atmosphere that invites families, friends, and pizza aficionados alike to savor every bite. Each pizza is a masterpiece, showcasing a blend of traditional and inventive flavors, all resting atop a perfectly charred crust. With a focus on quality ingredients and a passion for creating memorable dining experiences, Fat Zach’s Pizza stands out as a culinary gem in the heart of these two bustling neighborhoods.

Finding comfort and community in Puyallup's dining scene.
Finding comfort and community in Puyallup’s dining scene.  Source: pizzatrackside.com

Trackside Pizza takes pride in breathing new life into buildings of historic significance, including its home in a structure dating from the late 1800s to early 1900s, once known as the Puyallup Hotel. This establishment’s commitment to preserving history while serving high-quality food crafted from the freshest ingredients has made it a cherished part of the Puyallup community. Trackside isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a journey through time, where the ambiance complements the meticulously crafted pizzas, connecting diners to the history and heart of Puyallup.

Wicked Pie
Wicked Pie Pizza: A glimpse into one of Puyallup’s pizza jewels.  Source: bsrbranding.com

Meanwhile, Wicked Pie Pizza offers a twist on the traditional pizza experience with its adult-focused ambiance and menu. Targeting those desiring a break from the family-friendly norm, Wicked Pie promises an atmosphere where grown-up conversations and sophisticated drink options thrive. Their commitment to providing an exceptional experience is evident, from the gourmet ingredients to the eclectic decor. It stands as a testament to pizza’s versatility, successfully catering to a more mature palette and proving that pizza sophistication knows no bounds.

The heart of the pizza: A traditional oven that promises mouthwatering delights.
The heart of the pizza: A traditional oven that promises mouthwatering delights.
Source: therockwfp.com

The Rock Wood Fired Pizza brings a rock and roll twist to the pizza dining experience. Its blend of hand-picked ingredients, hand-tossed dough, and a hand-crafted menu guarantees an unforgettable culinary show. The ambiance, pulsing with good music and an eclectic atmosphere, makes every visit feel like you’re part of something extraordinary. It’s not just a meal; it’s an event, where the power of rock music and the universal love for pizza combine to create a standout spot in Puyallup’s pizza scene.

Puyallup Pizza, a family-owned cornerstone, emphasizes the value of community and convenience with its dedication to free delivery in Puyallup and surrounding areas. This spot may not boast the historical architecture or themed decor of its counterparts, yet it shines through its simplicity and focus on delivering quality pizza directly to your door. Here, the emphasis is on ensuring that families and friends can enjoy a delicious pizza experience in the comfort of their own homes, making it a pivotal part of the community’s fabric.

Each of these Puyallup pizza havens brings its own special features to the table, literally. From Fat Zach’s humble beginnings and wood fire masterpieces, to Trackside Pizza’s historical renovation, maintaining the charm of yesteryear, every restaurant offers more than just food—they provide an experience. Wicked Pie’s grown-up atmosphere and carefully curated drink menu cater to a niche audience, while The Rock’s engaging rock and roll vibe will make your taste buds rock & roll all night long. All of these restaurants emphasize the role pizza plays in bringing people together, even outside traditional restaurant settings.


Source: Fat Zach’s Pizza via DoorDash

Furthermore, the customization opportunities, unique combinations of toppings, and exclusive menu items like Wicked Pie’s pizza and cocktail pairings or The Rock’s music-inspired pizza selections, play into Puyallup’s narrative of diversity and creativity in pizza-making. It’s these special touches that not only distinguish each pizza spot but also enrich Puyallup’s pizza culture, ensuring there’s always something new to discover and a reason to come back for more.

Conclusively, Puyallup’s pizza scene is as varied as it is vibrant, boasting establishments that do more than just serve pizza; they cultivate experiences, foster community connections, and celebrate the city’s charm. As you venture through Puyallup’s streets and encounter its array of pizza spots, remember that each slice served is a piece of the communities heart, shared with love and a side of warmth.

So, whether you’re a local resident, a potential home buyer, or a business owner, exploring Puyallup’s pizza offerings promises not just a culinary adventure but an immersion into a community that values connection, history, and the simple joy of sharing a meal. Let’s continue to support and embrace these local gems, for in every pizza box lies an invitation to come together, creating memories that, just like pizza, are meant to be shared.